I went with the red pumps. This is the best picture I could get, and I'm feeling like it makes my hips look wider than they are. There is certainly plenty of room to spare around my tummy and hips, and I ran into an older woman wearing the same thing tonight! (Well, older as in six years.) But she said her mother had it, too! I just don't know if I'm ready for a cross-generational dress. I need to cling to my youth and pre-baby body as long as possible. It is a nice conservative, yet fun dress. I'm undecided.